(By Chambers Umezulike)

In ideal capitalist environments like in the United States of America, the public hospitals and schools are the best; equipped to the teeth; affordable, cheap, with subsidies and scholarships for the “have-nots”. These public institutions create a balance; and make competition between them and the privately run ones active. That is what it should in an ideal Capitalist environment. I do not know from where most African leaders got the idea that public institutions should die because of Capitalism.

Continued from last Tuesday (18-11-2014)

IN Nigeria, for an example, you would be seen as a joker if you send your ward to a public primary or secondary school because most of the public schools are dead. The unimaginable amount of money parents spend per term at these public schools is something else. I went to public primary and secondary schools. My primary school education was free, and I got quality education through passionate and good teachers, in a very conducive environment. My life today is built on that education. But this is not the case today; parents pay more than $500 per term at various privately run primary schools in Nigeria especially in Abuja and Lagos. You can imagine this. Then most of the public secondary schools are very much dead because of the government’s neglect and the sudden and rapid increase of privately run secondary schools helped to bring about mass cheatings in West African Senior Secondary Certificate, National Examination Council, and Joint Admission and Matriculation Examinations. The examination papers for these exams leak every morning across the federation during these exams, and most secondary school students do not read again during these very important exams.

   Then the elite that can afford it send their wards to big privately run secondary schools for quality education and where they pay more than $1,000 per term, in most instances. Then most public universities are dying also. Our father’s generations went to these public universities and always tell us stories about how good these universities were then, how emphasis were on quality education and conducive environment. The failure to sustain this, however, has given rise to privately run universities, run by mostly pastors and big politicians where students pay unimaginable sums of money to attend  because the public universities have been neglected in every sense: poor infrastructures; and always marred by strikes by Academic Staff Union of Universities and Non-Academic Staff Union of Universities. Currently, there is this whole wave of Nigerians going for university education abroad because the public universities are dying pretty fast. Dr. Nnamdi Azikiwe went to a university in the United States of America because Nigeria had no university then and for quality education. Decades later, Nigerians troop abroad for quality education. The best university in Nigeria is the University of Ilorin, a public university, and this university is the 20th in Africa based on the 2014 Webomectrics ranking of African universities; for you to understand what I am saying. Nigeria, with all her oil money, cannot boast of the best public university in Africa for example.

   Then you would be seen as a joke if you go to a public hospital in Nigeria for medical treatment, because most of them have been long neglected, with doctors that run their own private hospitals down town, and use the time they should have spent in these public hospitals where they were employed by the government, to run their private ones. I have cases of thousands of people that died not attended to, in these public hospitals during emergencies. Then the medical bills from these privately run hospitals are something else. If the public hospitals are working, at least the have-nots could afford going there for cheaper bills. These are common and essential things the government should provide. So to get the best services, education and health wise, one would have to go to the privately run institutions, and especially only the “haves” can afford this. Millions of Nigerians cannot afford visiting these privately run institutions. Many Nigerians have died from lack of money to travel abroad for major ailments like cancer and kidney cases. The elite in Nigeria (politicians, public office holders, wealthy business men) all go abroad for medical treatments, all of them. Including the president, his wife, former presidents, governors and key government officials all go abroad for medical treatment shamelessly. Many Nigerian politicians all died abroad while seeking for medical treatment over severe ailments because Nigeria cannot boast of public hospitals that could take care of some major ailments. It is saddening that Nigeria with all her oil money cannot boast of one of the best hospitals in the world.  The only crime in Nigeria is to be within the “have-nots.” And this is largely the case in most African countries.

   In ideal capitalist environments like in the United States of America, the public hospitals and schools are the best; equipped to the teeth; affordable, cheap, with subsidies and scholarships for the “have-nots”. These public institutions create a balance; and make competition between them and the privately run ones active. That is what it should in an ideal Capitalist environment. I do not know from where most African leaders got the idea that public institutions should die because of Capitalism.

   Moreover, another ugly fact is that most of the leaders in Africa that should make these Markets entirely free in the actual sense of Capitalism are the business people or have allies in the business sector. In most cases, during elections, the allies give them moneys to rig and bribe themselves through and when they get into power; they would have to reciprocate by given these business allies contracts and allowing them to have the monopoly of producing or importing very essential commodities. So you have the markets not being truly free again. There is serious monopoly in the importation and production of very essential commodities in most Africa countries. In Nigeria, a former Vice President has one of the costliest private universities in the country. Politicians own private schools, estates and hospitals.

  Then corruption sets in, because the Internally Generated Revenues that governments should generate from taxing these privately run institutions are not been used in most instances to deliver public goods, the way it should be in capitalist economies. Corruption takes away these taxes. In Europe, when you pay tax, you see the results the next day, but in most African countries, civil servants that have been paying taxes for years, for example, cannot point to anything and say that their taxes brought this. And based on poor legislative and judicial institutions, governments are not been held accountable for things like this.

   So in African capitalism, the poor keeps getting poorer and the rich richer. The poor ones, in millions, cannot get good health care or go to good schools in most cases, because the public institutions that should be thriving, cheaper, are not there to create a major balance. The elite are just the ones controlling everything while the masses are so impoverished. Welfarism is totally neglected. Public institutions are dying. Unlike in so many countries in the Scandinavia and Europe that have the best HDI’s in the world, and have their HDIs growing with their GDPs, like: Norway’s HDI is 0.955 (1st); Sweden, 0.898 (12th); Denmark, 0.900 (10th); Finland, 0.879, (24th); Germany, 0.911 (6th); Netherlands, 0.915 (4th) etc., there is a provision of public services: schools, hospitals, housing, transportation etc. Education and health care are free in most of these places and prices of essential commodities are very low. Some of these countries have economies that were built on Welfarism, why can’t African countries borrow from their model? They have been able to humanise their capitalism, even in almost all the countries in the West like the HDI of Australia is 0.933 (2nd); Switzerland, 0.917 (3rd); United States of America, 0.914 (5th); Ireland, 0.899 (11th); New Zealand, 0.910 (7th) ; Canada, 0.902 (8th) ; Belgium, 0.881 (21st); Austria, 0.811 (21st) etc.      They tell African countries to remove all the subsidies here, for their economies to thrive, while they have a lot of it over there like the Structural Adjustment Programmes experiences that caused inflation in so many African countries; caused intense poverty; caused great fall in the standard of living of so many people; made a lot of people lose their jobs; and messed up the social sectors through currency devaluation, higher taxes, lower government spending, rise in food prices, and cutting of wages. An average European has a good shelter, electricity, good food, efficient transportation etc., though they have gone far in economic growth and development for decades, their governments’ efforts, consciousness in making these provisions available, for almost everyone can never be neglected. They have capitalist economies but public services and Welfarism were never neglected. And people are living fairly well.

   I do not have any issues with capitalist economies, but African leaderships should not be carried away by this. There should be a bit of public deliveries and Welfarism. Economic growth without human development can never work. It is not by going to Davos and speaking good grammar, or showing everyone economic statistics or having smart finance ministers that borrow all the Western economic principles and come and heap them in Africa; but by clear facts about the living conditions of the people. Yes, I know about the trickle-down effect, but that might never work in Africa. Because Africans are so selfish, and it takes great time, and would take more time in the African context. People are grossly underpaid in most private institutions, there is abuse of labour; and I can feel the philanthropic presence of Bill Gate in Africa than that of all the richest African men combined altogether. African elite would prefer to go for shopping in Europe than in his or her country.

   Africa has made a lot of mistakes and is about starting a whole set of new ones again. Economic growth without human development can never help African countries. It is never by saying that the GDP is growing by this and that percentage and leaders prouding themselves in this regards but by, the translation of this, to the living conditions of the African people.

  It is time this becomes a concern to African leaders, the very fact that GDPs and HDIs are not working hand in hand, in most countries in Africa. Welfarism and public goods deliveries must be highly considered and not left out based on the wave of international capitalism, and based on the way African leaders are following it blindly. It’s not only by economic statistics but should be mainly by the standards of living of the African people.


Umezulike is an activist and writer

The YOUTHSPEAK Column which is published daily, on weekdays, on the back cover of THE GUARDIAN Newspaper, is powered by RISE NETWORKS, Nigeria’s Leading Youth and Education Development Social Enterprise, as a substantial advocacy platform available for ALL Nigerian Youth to engage Leadership at all levels, engage Society and contribute to National Discourse on diverse issues especially those that are peculiar to Nigeria.

Regarding submission of articles, we welcome writers’ contributions by way of well crafted, analytical and thought provoking opinion editorials that are concise, topical and non-defamatory! All Articles [which are not expected to be more than 1000 words] should be sent to editorial@risenetworks.org.

To read the online Version of this same article plus past publications and to find out more about Youth Speak, please click www.risenetworks.org/youthspeak and join the ongoing National Conversations.

“Opinion pieces of this sort published on RISE Networks are those of the original authors and do not in anyway represent the thoughts, beliefs and ideas of RISE Networks.”